Book: Disgrace

Author: J M Coetzee

Rating: 4/5

Disgrace-J M Coetzee

David Lurie is a professor of romantic poetry at a university in Capetown. He has been divorced twice and lives alone. For fulfilling his carnal urges, he has an occasional fling with women, both known and unknown. He is also a regular at a brothel for some time. His uneventful life suddenly takes an unpredictable turn when he is brought to disgrace by his student Melanie Isaacs with whom he was having a flitting and lustful affair. David is forced to quit his job. He decides to visit his only daughter Lucy who is living alone at her farm in rural South Africa.

Within days, David becomes inexorably mixed up with her daughter's affairs in this small township. Lucy is gang raped by 3 natives out of communal hatred, her farm is ravaged and David is attacked.

The author then narrates a complex story of coping with disgrace- by Lucy and David.

Social/Historical context:

The book, according to me, questions some age old notions of disgrace. While David falls to disgrace for allegedly violating a young girl, his daughter is brutally gang raped by 3 men who go scot-free. David's attraction towards Melanie is mostly sexual in nature. But David cares deeply for Melanie and wishes her well being. Yet, by the standards of David's society, he is judged guilty of a grave offense in establishing physical contact with his student. David is forced to forgo his livelihood and surrenders to a life of disgrace. “You have lost your job, your name is mud, your friends avoid you, you hide out in Torrance Road like a tortoise afraid to stick its neck out of its shell.”

On the other hand, Lucy, who is a lesbian, has been violently raped by 3 natives out of communal hatred. She has to pay a very high price for choosing to live a life of her own volition. She has been brought to disgrace because of this, while the perpetrators of this injustice are not brought to book. The rapists even exercise a moral high ground and exult over their exploit. The rapists are supported by their clan.

The stark difference in the fate of the disgraced and the disgracer throws open various questions on the meaning of disgrace, it's genesis and repercussion.

Writing Style:

Coetzee uses the direct narrative form where David Lurie depicts the sequence of events in his and his daughter's life. The language is straight forward, prosaic and conversational. The book should be very easy read for most.

My Thoughts:

I was profoundly impressed by this book. The author is very sensitive to his subject and is able to raise a lot of questions on 'Disgrace' with the clever use of perspectives. It is interesting to see how David's ex-wife, the farm help Petrus, Lucy, Lucy's close friends, Melanie's father and various such characters react to 'Disgrace'.

Thanks to Coetzee, this little researched subject of 'Disgrace' is brought to focus. The author tells us how Disgrace takes on various connotations in different societies, in various professions, in various age groups.....

Overall, a very complex topic handled beautifully.

Book Reviewed By Ashmita Saha

Read other Booker Prize winning book reviews here

Enter Your E-mail Address
Enter Your First Name (optional)

Don't worry — your e-mail address is totally secure.
I promise to use it only to send you Book Lovers Club News.

Write a book review and get a web page dedicated to yourself! Click Here

Got an opinion on this book?

Did you read this book too? Got an opinion on it? Share it!

What Other Visitors Have Said

Click below to see contributions from other visitors to this page...

Yes definitely. I would read it again if I hadn't loaned to a friend who never returned it. Not rated yet
An excellent read which brought up more questions than it answered for me. It really is a book worth reading more than once and I think it is nowhere …

Click here to write your own.


Nice site(I like the eating books concept!)
-Maggie Ball

Dear Ashmita,
Allow me to congratulate you on your constant efforts at keeping the love for literature and the love for reading constant -amongst us netizens by regularly posting quizzes and information as this current read on Pulitzer prizes! Excellent!
Warm wishes,

Thank you Ashmita. And I would like to take this as an opportunity to express my appreciation of the effort that has gone into the making of such a fabulous website.
-Amrita Dutta

I would like to take an opportunity to congratulate you for all your efforts in creating such an insightful and informative Group ( Book Review Circle) It is surely a great platform to gather and learn more about like-minded people.
-Jai Prakash Dangwal

This was really a wonderful piece of information. It was enriching and educating. Thank You.

I am amazed at the number of reviews and the wide range of books you have read and written about. Really impressive!

Without the educative literary information from you I feel spiritually dry. Nice to hear from you.
-Palashpriya Bose Jaiswal

It was interesting to know about the significance and use of diary entries in the world of writing. I read something like this for the first time, so I thank and congratulate you for your choice of topic :-)