Book: Oscar And Lucinda

Author: Peter Carey

Rating: 3/5

Oscar And Lucinda-Peter Carey

An intriguing tale of how a certain church was built in rural Australia by the curious manipulations of fate in the lives of Oscar Hopkins and Lucinda Leplastrier. Oscar is a church man. Lucinda is a rich young woman dabbling in the glass factory business. The two meet because of their obsessive love for gambling. Gambling entwines their fates. Gambling makes them fall in love. Gambling leads to the denouement of the plot in the creation and locomotion of the church of glass. The tale is full of incidents with unpredictable quirky ends which create a complex plot. The biggest such twist comes at the end of the novel when Oscar and Lucinda both experience their tragic fallout. As a reader I found this sudden twist at the end to be most delightful.

Social/Historical context:

The book is set in Australia in the 1800s. Much of Australia was inhabited by aboriginals and was underdeveloped at that time. The Christian Church was sending its emissaries to these rural parts of Australia while trying to civilise it. The book bears reference to this aspect of history. We get glimpses of social customs and prejudices belonging to this time in Australia. Gender bias is a predominant theme. We see how Lucinda, a single young heiress tries to hold her ground in a society unused to authority from women.

Writing Style:

The book is written in the third person narrative, by an omniscient author who can get into the minds of all characters in the novel and narrate events from their individual perspectives. The book reads like an epic with numerous small incidents and characters who don’t always contribute significantly to the plot. For example, why did Oscar’s best friend, Wardley-Fish unsuccessfully try to follow Oscar’s journey to Boat Harbour? Why he was even made to come to Australia in pursuit of Oscar? Why do we need to know the life history of Fanny Drabble, Theophilus Hopkins’ servant? I don’t think such detours contribute significantly to the story.

My Thoughts:

If the author meant this to be a love story, I don’t think he has been successful in creating one. Yes, Oscar and Lucinda do fall in love and Oscar dies because of it. But romance is hardly the theme of the novel. The two fall in love well beyond the second half of the book. They meet when half the book is over. And the plot hardly concentrates on the emotional development of their romance. The two seem more like loners who get together simply because they are unable to find anyone else. Lucinda is spurned by her first and only other love interest, Dennis Hasset. Oscar does not seem capable of any predominant emotional affiliation in the haze of his fears and complexes. One wonders, can someone as weak as Oscar experience something as elevating as Love?

Book Reviewed By Ashmita Saha

Read other Booker Prize winning book reviews here

Enter Your E-mail Address
Enter Your First Name (optional)

Don't worry — your e-mail address is totally secure.
I promise to use it only to send you Book Lovers Club News.

Write a book review and get a web page dedicated to yourself! Click Here

Got an opinion on this book?

Did you read this book too? Got an opinion on it? Share it!


Nice site(I like the eating books concept!)
-Maggie Ball

Dear Ashmita,
Allow me to congratulate you on your constant efforts at keeping the love for literature and the love for reading constant -amongst us netizens by regularly posting quizzes and information as this current read on Pulitzer prizes! Excellent!
Warm wishes,

Thank you Ashmita. And I would like to take this as an opportunity to express my appreciation of the effort that has gone into the making of such a fabulous website.
-Amrita Dutta

I would like to take an opportunity to congratulate you for all your efforts in creating such an insightful and informative Group ( Book Review Circle) It is surely a great platform to gather and learn more about like-minded people.
-Jai Prakash Dangwal

This was really a wonderful piece of information. It was enriching and educating. Thank You.

I am amazed at the number of reviews and the wide range of books you have read and written about. Really impressive!

Without the educative literary information from you I feel spiritually dry. Nice to hear from you.
-Palashpriya Bose Jaiswal

It was interesting to know about the significance and use of diary entries in the world of writing. I read something like this for the first time, so I thank and congratulate you for your choice of topic :-)